I've ordered multiple pin designs over the past few months and while overall they usually look nice, it averages out that out of an order of 50 per design, at least 50% will have scratches or divets in the acrylic every time. Most of them are not as noticeable from far away however but if you're selling it to be a mini collectible just expect to have 50% of them be B-grade quality and you'll be fine. Customer service is typically pretty nice and quick to respond if a particular batch of pins had excessive poor quality issues and a few replacement pins have been sent before on my previous orders.
Like this? It's easy to order your own custom pins too 🙂